Evicting Einstein

A physics experiment on the drawing board for the International Space Station could help find the grand unifying "Theory of Everything."

Source Document: Evicting Einstein

March 26, 2004:  Sooner or later, the reign of Einstein, like the reign of Newton before him, will come to an end. An upheaval in the world of physics that will overthrow our notions of basic reality is inevitable, most scientists believe, and currently a horse race is underway between a handful of theories competing to be the successor to the throne.

Commentary on New Theory

Whatever theory replaces Einstein's Relativity, it is being made very sure, today, that it can be measured and that both measurement and measurers of causes are opposite to Reality, just like Einstein's theories were.

In the running are such mind-bending ideas as an 11-dimensional universe, universal "constants" (such as the strength of gravity) that vary over space and time and only remain truly fixed in an unseen 5th dimension, infinitesimal vibrating strings as the fundamental constituents of reality, and a fabric of space and time that's not smooth and continuous, as Einstein believed, but divided into discrete, indivisible chunks of vanishingly small size. Experiment will ultimately determine which triumphs.

Right:According to Einstein's theory of general relativity, the sun's gravity causes starlight to bend, shifting the apparent position of stars in the sky.

A new concept for an experiment to test the predictions of Einstein's relativity more precisely than ever before is being developed by scientists at NASA's Jet Propulsion Laboratory (JPL). Their mission, which effectively uses our solar system as a giant laboratory, would help narrow the field of vying theories and bring us one step closer to the next revolution in physics.

Commentary on Light Bending

If you are so sure of your "incredible precision" by which you can confirm Einstein's "light bending by gravity", then why can you not precisely understand that light exists only near matter, that there is no light in deep space, that suns have no gravity in themselves, all stars repel all other stars, gravity in open space is a repellent phenomena and that the optical medium space bends nothing except itself?

It may not weigh heavily on most people's minds, but a great schism has long plagued our fundamental understanding of the universe. Two ways of explaining the nature and behavior of space, time, matter, and energy currently exist: Einstein's relativity and the "standard model" of quantum mechanics. Both are extremely successful. The Global Positioning System (GPS), for instance, wouldn't be possible without the theory of relativity. Computers, telecommunications, and the Internet, meanwhile, are spin-offs of quantum mechanics.

But the two theories are like different languages, and no one is yet sure how to translate between them. Relativity explains gravity and motion by uniting space and time into a 4-dimensional, dynamic, elastic fabric of reality called space-time, which is bent and warped by the energy it contains. (Mass is one form of energy, so it creates gravity by warping space-time.)

Commentary on Twisting, Warping and Precession.

If you are so sure of your "incredible precision" by which you can confirm Einstein's "space twisting caused by mass", then why can you not precisely understand that Birklund space currents twist by themselves?

If you are so sure of your "incredible precision" by which you can confirm Einstein's "geodetic precession caused by mass", then why can you not precisely understand that geodetic precession was three orthogonal movements of space even before mass existed?

Quantum mechanics, on the other hand, assumes that space and time form a flat, immutable "stage" on which the drama of several families of particles unfolds. These particles can move both forward and backward in time (something relativity doesn't allow), and the interactions between these particles explain the basic forces of nature -- with the glaring exception of gravity.


Astronomers use the light-bending properties of gravity to view very distant galaxies--such as the arc shapes in this image--in a technique called "gravitational lensing." [More]

The stalemate between these two theories has gone on for decades. Most scientists assume that somehow, eventually, a unifying theory will be developed that subsumes the two, showing how the truths they each contain can fit neatly within a single, all-encompassing framework of reality. Such a "Theory of Everything" would profoundly affect our knowledge of the birth, evolution, and eventual fate of the universe.

Slava Turyshev, a scientist at JPL, and his colleagues have thought of a way to use the International Space Station (ISS) and two mini-satellites orbiting on the far side of the sun to test the theory of relativity with unprecedented accuracy. Their concept, developed in part through funding from NASA's Office of Biological and Physical Research, would be so sensitive that it could reveal flaws in Einstein's theory, thus providing the first hard data needed to distinguish which of the competing Theories of Everything agree with reality and which are merely fancy chalk-work.

Commentary on The Nature of Light

If you are so sure of your "incredible precision" by which you can confirm Einstein's "186,283 mps velocity of light", then why can you not precisely understand that this velocity is the velocity of space?

The experiment, called Laser Astrometric Test Of Relativity (LATOR), would look at how the sun's gravity deflects beams of laser light emitted by the two mini-satellites. Gravity bends the path of light because it warps the space through which the light is passing.

The standard analogy for this warping of space-time by gravity is to imagine space as a flat sheet of rubber that stretches under the weight of objects like the sun. The depression in the sheet would cause an object (even a no-mass particle of light) passing nearby the sun to turn slightly as it went by.

In fact, it was by measuring the bending of starlight by the sun during a solar eclipse in 1919 that Sir Arthur Eddington first tested Einstein's theory of general relativity. In cosmic terms, the sun's gravity is fairly weak; the path of a beam of light skimming the edge of the sun would only be bent by about 1.75 arcseconds (an arcsecond is 1/3600 of a degree). Within the limits of accuracy of his measuring equipment, Eddington showed that starlight did indeed bend by this amount -- and in doing so effectively impeached Newton.

LATOR would measure this deflection with a billion (109) times the precision of Eddington's experiment and 30,000 times the precision of the current record-holder: a serendipitous measurement using signals from the Cassini spacecraft on its way to explore Saturn.

Above:The curvature of space due to the sun's mass caused signals from the Cassini probe to curve on their way to Earth. [More]

"I think [LATOR] would be quite an important advance for fundamental physics," says Clifford Will, a professor of physics at Washington University who has made major contributions to post-Newtonian physics and is not directly involved with LATOR. "We should continue to try to press for more accuracy in testing general relativity, simply because any kind of deviation would mean that there's new physics that we were not aware of before."

Commentary on Gravity

If you are so sure of your "incredible precision" by which you can confirm Einstein's "gravity is caused by mass", then why can you not precisely understand that gravity is what space does?

Solar laboratory

The experiment would work like this: Two small satellites, each about one meter wide, would be launched into an orbit circling the sun at roughly the same distance as Earth. This pair of mini-satellites would orbit more slowly than Earth does, so about 17 months after launch, the mini-satellites and Earth would be on opposite sides of the sun. Even though the two satellites would be about 5 million km apart, the angle between them as viewed from Earth would be tiny, only about 1 degree. Together, the two satellites and Earth would form a skinny triangle, with laser beams along its sides, and one of those beams passing close to the sun.

Above:A schematic diagram of the proposed LATOR mission.

Turyshev plans to measure the angle between the two satellites using an interferometer mounted on the ISS. An interferometer is a device that catches and combines beams of light. By measuring how waves of light from the two mini-satellites "interfere" with each other, the interferometer can measure the angle between the satellites with extraordinary precision: about 10 billionthsof an arcsecond, or 0.01 µas (micro-arcseconds). When the precision of the other parts of the LATOR design are considered, this gives an overall accuracy for measuring how much gravity bends the laser beam of about 0.02 µas for a single measurement.

"Using the ISS gives us a few advantages," Turyshev explains. "For one, it's above the distortions of Earth's atmosphere, and it's also large enough to let us place the two lenses of the interferometer far apart (one lens on each end of the solar panel truss), which improves the resolution and accuracy of the results."

Left:The interferometer will be mounted to the solar-panel truss of the ISS, which automatically rotates to continuously face the sun. Image courtesy Slava Turyshev.

The 0.02 µas accuracy of LATOR is good enough to reveal deviations from Einstein's relativity predicted by the aspiring Theories of Everything, which range from roughly 0.5 to 35 µas. Agreement with LATOR's measurements would be a major boost for any of these theories. But if no deviation from Einstein is found even by LATOR, most of the current contenders--along with their 11 dimensions, pixilated space, and inconstant constants--will suffer a fatal blow and "pass on" to that great dusty library stack in the sky.

Because the mission requires only existing technologies, Turyshev says LATOR could be ready to fly as soon as 2009 or 2010. So it may not be too long before the stalemate in physics is broken and a new theory of gravity, space, and time takes the throne.

Credits & Contacts
Author: Patrick L. Barry
Responsible NASA official: Ron Koczor

Production Editor: Dr. Tony Phillips
Curator: Bryan Walls
Media Relations: Steve Roy

The Science Directorate at NASA's Marshall Space Flight Center sponsors the Science@NASA web sites. The mission of Science@NASA is to help the public understand how exciting NASA research is and to help NASA scientists fulfill their outreach responsibilities.

Web Links

NASA's Office of Biological and Physical Research (OBPR) supports studies like Turyshev's for the benefit of humans in space and on Earth

Laser Astrometric Test Of Relativity (LATOR) -- technical paper by Turyshev and colleagues about the LATOR concept

Many of the candidates for a "Theory of Everything" predict the existence of a scalar field that permeates the universe. Einstein first proposed such a field when he introduced a cosmological constant into his equations for gravity. He later changed his mind and removed this term, but recently the idea has garnered renewed interest among physicists. Such a term could account for the surprising discovery that the expansion of the universe is actually accelerating, not slowing down as physicists previously thought. Like the famous Michelson-Morley experiment in 1887 that sought to detect the existence of the "aether", LATOR will be able to determine whether the scalar field exists -- a finding that will be pivotal in the search for a Theory of Everything.

Einstein's Relativity and Everyday Life -- Physicist Clifford Will explains how the Global Positioning System depends on the theory of relativity.

The Theory of Everything-- article about the search for a theory to unify relativity with quantum mechanics, by physicist Michio Kaku

A Pop Quiz for Einstein -- (Science@NASA) The Gravity Probe B mission will test two important aspects of Einstein's theory of General Relativity.

The Elegant Universe-- Watch a 3 hour series from PBS's Nova about the quest to find a unifying Theory of Everything

"Laser Astrometric Test of Relativity (LATOR) Mission Studies" is just one of many fundamental physics research grants recently awarded by NASA's Office of Biological and Physical Sciences.

General Relativity-- Introduction to general relativity, from the Wikipedia

Join our growing list of subscribers - sign up for our express news delivery and you will receive a mail message every time we post a new story!!!

Moresays 'NASA NEWS' Headlines


Impossible Correspondence Index

Copyright. Robert Grace. 2004.