Celebrating
the Dead in San Francisco
Dias De Los Muertos - Celebrating
Death
Story by: Nicole
Lee
Skulls and coffins
adorned the heart of the Mission district the
evening of Nov. 2. Among them were ghosts and
goblins, skeletal figures with darkened eyes
and whitened cheeks, and flamboyant, gory
beasts. Surrounding the figures was an intense
scent of sage and incense that permeated the
air.
These revelers didn't forget Halloween was
on Oct. 31. They were in a parade procession
to celebrate Dia
de los Muertos, otherwise known as the Day
of the Dead.
The procession started at the corner of
24th and Bryant streets, and proceeded along
to 25th, Mission, back to 24th, through Balmy
Alley, and finally ended in Garfield Park with
a public ritual.
It was the final day of the three-day Dia
de Los Muertos celebration, a traditional
Mexican festival that honors death and treats
it as a continuation of life, rather than the
end of it.
This is a ritual that indigenous peoples of
Mexico, then known as Aztecs, practiced for at
least 3,000 years. Unlike the Spaniards that
conquered them, they believed one should
embrace death instead of fearing it.
The San Francisco Day of the Dead Ritual
Procession is a project of the Colectivo del
Rescate Cultural, that was produced in
collaboration with CELL Space and Reclaiming
Collective, Spiritual and Cultural Workers,
Community Educational & Artistic
Organizations, the Mission Cultural Center,
the Mexican Museum, Galeria De La Raza, the
California Arts Council Folk Arts Program, and
Independent Artists.
Most people take the opportunity during
this celebration to pay homage to dead friends
and relatives.
In rural Mexico, people visit the cemetery
where their loved ones are buried, and
decorate the gravesites. In the United States
and in Mexico's larger cities, families build
altars in their homes, dedicating them to the
dead.
During the procession, the beating of drums
and the ringing of bells echoed through the
otherwise quiet evening. Several groups had
their own drum procession, while individuals
used old glasses as makeshift percussion
instruments to join in the celebration.
"The sounds of the drums indicate
happiness," said Javier Pinzon, one of a
group of people who were carrying tall sticks
adorned with colorful paper streamers.
"The more sound there is, the happier the
atmosphere is".
The tall sticks were part of this year's
procession ritual theme, which honored the
re-birth of Quetzalcoatl, an Aztec god who
brought culture and enlightenment to the
Aztecs. Several tall sticks of pink and purple
streamers formed the tail of the god, whereas
the head of the god was a huge cross adorned
with different colored streamers. The center
of the cross was a bright orange-yellow color.
People donned wooden skull masks called
"calacas" and danced in honor of
their deceased relatives. Assistants passed
out yellow marigolds to the crowd. Dancers
hopped and skipped along the darkened road,
lit only by streetlights and candles carried
by celebrants.
"The candles are to light the way home
for the spirits," said Raquel Garcia.
Garcia works part time as an artist who
occasionally builds altars in museums, such as
the San Francisco Museum of Modern Art.
"The incense is to attract the spirits
by smell, and the yellow marigold [also called
cempazuchitl] is the symbol of death,"
Garcia said. "The skeleton costumes and
such are mostly for fun."
Garcia's grandmother died five years ago,
so Garcia said she tries to attend this
celebration every year in remembrance of her.
"This is a peaceful and joyful
celebration," she said. "I believe
that the spirits are still alive, and my
grandmother is still around enjoying
this."
Participant Joanna Moody was dressed up as
a corpse; her face painted as a grey and black
skull. She pushed her 2-year-old son in a blue
stroller along in the parade. Moody has
attended the Dia de los Muertos parade for
many years, but this was her son's first.
"It's a family event, and kids can get
involved," Moody said. "We get
reunited with our beloved dead relatives,
especially those that died the last
year."
A truck drove up Bryant Street, and
standing on it was Gerardo Salina as a
towering Aztec priest dressed in a golden
rooster outfit, with long flamboyant plumage
and bells on his shoes. He stood on the truck,
beating a huge drum. Behind him were several
female dancers, dressed up in similar golden
outfits. He led the colorful god formation
through the parade.
A group of four people carried a
coffin-shaped metal frame through the crowd.
When looked at closely, shapes of flattened
guns decorated the frame. The man who built
it, John Ricker, the founder and executive
director of Peaceful Streets, used about 30
guns to create his art.
"We want to get guns and turn them
into art," Ricker said. "This is
built out of donated guns. For every dollar a
gun is worth, a book will be donated to a
reading program. So, this gun showed on the
side here was worth $200, therefore 200 books
will be donated."
The organization has been around for three
years. The goal is to get a gun for every
person killed. For example, 68 people have
been killed so far this year, so they hope to
get 68 guns donated, according to Ricker.
The procession ended at Garfield Park.
There were four different altars, symbolizing
earth, fire, air and water, that various local
artists helped build. Each altar was
elaborately designed with candles, pictures
and sculptures scattered around it. One had
little pet statues and crosses, as well as
paper drawings of children. People were
invited to take a piece of paper and write a
little note to a departed loved one, and then
leave them on the ground in front of the
altar. By the end of the night, the ground was
littered with pieces of torn paper that
carried personal messages to the deceased.
FROM: http://130.212.44.5/storys01.php?storyid=1959
|
|
- mal
de ojo
(the "evil eye")
- a kind of personalistic illness in Latin America
and parts of the Mediterranean Basin resulting from soul loss.
The cause is traditionally thought to be a strong person
staring at a weak individual. The eyes of the strong
person drain the power and/or soul from the weak one.
Proof that this has occurred to someone is that he or she
cries inconsolably without a cause, has fitful sleep,
diarrhea, vomiting, and/or a fever. It is thought that
powerful people can cause this draining of the soul
intentionally or unintentionally. In traditional Mexican
and Central American culture, women, babies, and young
children are thought of as being weak, while men as well
as rich and politically powerful people of either gender are
strong. People who believe in the existence of mal de
ojo are likely to seek out a curandero to cure it.
curandero
(female: curandera )
a Latin American folk
curer. Cuanderos believe that they have received a
divine calling to their profession, and they may have direct
contact with the spirit world. They usually apprentice for
years under an older curandero. In Mexico and
Central America, there are curandero generalists and
specialists. Yerberos
are knowledgeable about herbs. Parteras
are midwifes. Sabadoros
are specialists in massaging patients. Curanderos
may also specialize in particular kinds of illness--e.g., curandero
de aire ,
etc.
Illegal Immigrant Death Rate Rises Sharply in Barren Areas
By EVELYN NIEVES
EL
CENTRO, Calif. The dying season began early here this year, with
four bloated bodies found floating in the All-American Canal on
March 14. The victims, young men ages 19 and 20, had made their way
from Chiapas, in southernmost Mexico, before drowning in the canal's
churning currents just 35 yards from United States land.
For the Imperial County Sheriff's Department, it was an
ominous sign. The dead usually start showing up in multiples in high
summer, when the desert becomes an inferno and the canal, roiling
beneath a calm veneer, lures migrants looking for a quick way across
and relief from the killing sun. If bodies were washing up in groups
in March, what would the summer be like?
The answer, so far, is grim. Even though deaths along the
Mexican border have declined over all as the slumping American
economy has attracted fewer migrants, the toll is reaching record
rates in the most remote and dangerous outposts. To avoid the
stepped-up border patrols in populated areas, the most desperate
migrants cross in the more unguarded and desolate deserts of Arizona
and eastern California. June was the deadliest month ever for the
southwest border, with 67 migrants dying, mostly in the unrelenting
heat of the United States Border Patrol's Tucson sector, a barely
habitable land that covers most of southern Arizona.
Here in the mountainous El Centro sector, which includes the
vast Imperial Desert, 52 migrants have died since Oct. 1. The
sheriff's department believes the deaths could outpace last year's
record of 95.
"It seems quiet, but we're finding more multiples bodies
in threes, fours and fives," said Gary Hayes, a deputy coroner
in the department. "They're really trying to avoid detection,
so they're going to more and more remote areas."
The rising toll in these barren regions is the more remarkable
because illegal immigration from Mexico has fallen 29 percent,
largely because of the faltering United States economy and tighter
security, and border deaths in general are down 20 percent.
Experts warn that the deadliest months are to come. August,
traditionally, is the cruelest. They also note that the statistics
do not include people who die in Mexico. (The Mexican government
counted 22 migrants who died inside its border in June. It counts
only Mexicans and not migrants who pass through from Central America
or elsewhere.)
The deaths are full of suffering. People have suffocated in
airless trucks, died in vehicle crashes, been struck by lightning or
drowned. Most often, though, they are felled by heatstroke or
dehydration. Some carry no identification and, in a tragic irony,
end up where they wanted to be, in the United States but in
anonymous pauper's graves. Other migrants, not counted by the Border
Patrol, never make it across.
Migrant advocacy organizations blame the Border Patrol for the
mounting deaths, saying that its decision to focus its policing on
border cities has driven migrant traffic to the most severe terrain,
with the most extreme climates, winter and summer. The policy, which
began as Operation Gatekeeper in 1994, added officers, enhanced
surveillance equipment and put up physical barriers like concrete
walls, as well as introducing other measures, at the San Diego
border. The strategy was then expanded to Arizona and Texas.
Since the operation began, about 2,000 migrants have died
trying to cross into this country, according to the Mexican
government, with an average of more than one a day in the last two
years. The shift has also made expensive smugglers called coyotes
indispensable. Possibly hundreds of migrants have died because they
have been abandoned by these smugglers, or because they have been
led by people who themselves could not manage a brutal landscape,
their advocates say.
"Once the deaths started happening by the dozens in the
mountains east of San Diego," the federal government
"never rethought its strategy," said Claudia Smith, border
project director for the California Rural Legal Assistance
Foundation, in San Diego. "The Border Patrol, as planned, went
on to push them into the deserts," she said, "where the
risk increased exponentially."
The Border Patrol denies that its policies are responsible for
the increase in deaths and has no plans to change its strategy. It
counters that it is doing everything it can to deter migrants from
passing through the desert, including adding medically trained
search and trauma teams to rescue migrants, helicopter patrols in
treacherous areas and several rescue beacons in the desert that send
an electronic distress signal with the push of a button. It has also
mounted a public service campaign in Mexico and Central America,
using celebrities to do television and radio advertisements to warn
would-be migrants of the dangers of trying an illegal border
crossing.
"Our primary mission is to protect our nation's
borders," said Mario Villarreal, a spokesman for the Border
Patrol in Washington, D.C., adding that unscrupulous smugglers,
charging between $1,000 and $2,000 a person or more, are to blame
for persuading would-be border crossers to make the dangerous trek.
Crossing the border illegally has always come with risks.
Before Operation Gatekeeper, most traffic entered via cities like
San Diego and El Paso, where migrants became targets for muggers and
the like.
A study released in July by the Public Policy Institute of
California, a research organization in San Francisco, found that the
Gatekeeper strategy, which costs more than $2 billion a year, has
done little to significantly diminish illegal immigration. It
actually increased after the border buildup. Economic opportunities
in the United States and Mexico, the study found, have a stronger
effect on migration than does the number of agents at the border.
Migrants risking their lives in the extremes of the desert
tend to come from the poorest states in Mexico, like Chiapas and
Oaxaca, where the economy is in collapse and whole villages have
been vacated by working-age men, and, increasingly, women. At Casa
Madre de Asunto in Tijuana, a safe house for migrant women that is
run by a Catholic nun, a dozen or more women at a time have either
migrated to the city from the south or have stopped by on their way
to cross the border.
Recently, a 31-year-old woman from Oaxaca said she and her
brother, a cousin and a friend, who were resting at a safe house for
men next door, had driven for two days and two nights to make it to
Tijuana and planned to make a two-day trek through mountains with a
"coyote" who was taking them into Los Angeles, charging
them $1,500 each.
"That's $1,000 less than he charges others," she
said, "because he knows us." She had tried to make the
trek months before, she said, but lost her nerve after feeling faint
and dehydrated and turned back after a day.
She said she hoped to become a maid or work in a store and
make some money to send to her mother. "I'm coming for a better
life for all of us," she said.
Days later, a woman at the safe house said she assumed the
group had made it across; they had not heard from the Oaxaca woman.
When smugglers are caught, said Mr. Villarreal of the Border
Patrol, efforts are made to prosecute them. In a recent incident in
Dallas, where two men were found dead in a stifling 54-foot-long
truck that had transported 40 illegal immigrants from El Paso, a
nine-hour trip, two truckers have been charged with murder.
"This is good work' but we're not done," Mr.
Villarreal said. "The main message we still want to get out is
that it is dangerous to try to cross along the southwest
border."
Here in the El Centro sector, five suspected illegal
immigrants died of heat exposure in mid-July in an area of the
Imperial Desert that resembles a moonscape. "It's almost
totally devoid of plant life," Mr. Hayes, the deputy coroner,
said.
Spotted by a military aircraft, the bodies could not retrieved
for a day because of the terrain. Mr. Hayes said satellite equipment
was needed to mark the positions of the bodies.
FROM: http://threehegemons.tripod.com/threehegemonsblog/id152.html
|
|
Mexico: Returns, Politics, Death Row
In February 2004, Mexico and the US agreed that Mexicans
apprehended in the US just inside the border could volunteer to be
returned to their communities of origin rather than be simply bussed
back to the border. The intent is to discourage migrants from making
repeated attempts to enter the US. Asa Hutchinson, US undersecretary
of border and transportation security, said "If we can move
migrants back into the interior, closer to their homes, we can
achieve our goal to break the cycle of smuggling."
The US is trying to persuade Mexico to see border control as a
humanitarian issue, arguing that if Mexico helped to discourage
illegal entries, the lives of migrants who now perish in the desert
could be saved. Some say that the test will come in summer 2004. If
Mexico helps to reduce illegal entries, the stage may be set for the
Bush administration to argue that Mexico-US cooperation can make
broader immigration reform work.
In September 2003, the US spent $1.3 million to fly 5,600 Mexicans
apprehended in Arizona to Texas border cities and walked them across
the border. The Mexican government protested, saying that it wanted
"a bilateral agreement on how to discourage illegal
migration" rather than unilateral US policy initiatives.
Mexico in March 2004 arrested 44 persons for smuggling, including 32
former officials of the National Immigration Institute, Mexico's
border enforcement agency. Those arrested were charged with
smuggling Brazilians, Cubans, Central Americans and Asians through
Mexico into the United States.
Jaripo, Michoacan, six hours northwest of Mexico City, is a city
of nurseries and nursing homes that survives from remittances and
the return of migrants from Lathrop, near Stockton, every
December-January. A reporter concluded: "Emigration to the
United States encourages more people to emigrate, while stunting the
region's ability to develop its own economy" because wage
expectations are formed by what relatives earn in the US. Jaripo
children tend to drop out of school at 15 and head for the US.
Politics. Homemade videos of Mexico City officials stuffing bribes
in brief-cases prompted Mexico City Mayor Andres Manuel Lopez
Obrador, a leading presidential contender for 2006, to assert that
"The fundamental problem of our country -- corruption -- hasn't
been solved. . . . As long as there is corruption, we can't get
ahead." Millions of Mexicans refuse to pay income and property
taxes because of a widespread belief that the money will end up in
an official's pocket.
In the aftermath of the bribery videos, Mexico's political parties
agreed to reform the financing of parties and elections: Mexico
spends $1.2 billion on elections, the most in Latin America, and
more than it spends on public safety. Under the proposed reforms,
the amount of money given to parties and spent on elections would
fall, and Mexicans abroad would gain the right to vote.
President Fox in March 2004 proposed major reforms of the criminal
justice system, including the presumption of innocence, public
trials with oral evidence, and introducing plea bargaining. The five
federal police forces would be combined into one national entity,
and police would be given new investigative powers. Under current
procedures, people are sometimes arrested on dubious suspicions for
minor crimes and held for months without charges; an estimated 80
percent of crimes are not reported because Mexicans have so little
faith in the police.
Vienna Convention. Mexico challenged the death sentences of 51
Mexican citizens in eight US states for crimes committed in the US.
On the ground that the rights of the Mexicans were not protected
under the Vienna Convention on Consular Relations. That treaty
requires arresting officers to allow foreigners to contact their
diplomatic representatives. The US became a party to the Convention
in 1969; there are 164 signatories.
The International Court of Justice in The Hague agreed with Mexico
that, because state and local police and prosecutors did not provide
consular access to the Mexicans, those on death row should have the
opportunity to reopen and reargue their cases. Mexican lawyers told
the court that in the cases when consular protection was provided,
life sentences were more likely than death sentences.
In January 2004, there were 122 foreign citizens from 31 countries
on death row in the United States. The US government says that it
has distributed pocket cards to 700,000 law enforcement officials in
18,000 state and local jurisdictions informing them of suspects'
rights to consular access.
Guatemala Border. In 2003, Mexico deported 147,000 illegal
immigrants, about 20 percent more than in 2002, with 90 percent from
Honduras, Guatemala and Nicaragua. Many gather in Tecum Uman, and
cross the Suchiate river into Mexico from Guatemala.
Many migrants try to board so-called trains of death that travel
from the Mexico border city of Tapachula 1,000 miles to
Texas-Mexican border. Corrupt police and criminals prey on the
migrants; the Mexican Grupo Beta agents try to protect the migrants
and warn them of the dangers of riding the trains north.
Hugh Dellios, "Seeking the train of death," Chicago
Tribune, March 12, 2004. Sam Quinones, "Emigration brings
dollars home but leaves Mexican town behind," San Francisco
Chronicle, February 9, 2004. "Mexico's immigration
problem" The Economist, January 29, 2004.
FROM: http://migration.ucdavis.edu/mn/more.php?id=2997_0_2_0
|
|
NAFTA Equals Death, Say Peasant Farmers
Inter Press Service
December 04, 2002
Diego Cevallos
MEXICO CITY, Dec 3 (IPS) - More than 2,000 peasant farmers from
throughout Mexico staged a protest Tuesday in the capital to demand
a freeze on the agricultural provisions of the North American Free
Trade Agreement (NAFTA), which they blame for most of their economic
and social woes.
But their demands do not appear to have much chance of winning
the desired response from the government.
''I have nothing. I am here out of desperation because I am
poorer than I have ever been,'' said Francisco Martmnez, an elderly
farmer who took part in Tuesday's march in Mexico City, carrying a
sign that read ''NAFTA Equals Death''.
Under the slogan ''the countryside can endure no more'',
farmers from 24 of Mexico's 32 states marched in Mexico City to the
Congress building to present their demands and later staged protests
outside the U.S. and French embassies.
UNORCA, the national union of some 30 regional peasant groups,
organized the demonstrations with the aim of preventing the
agricultural trade liberalization measures -- agreed under NAFTA,
which comprises Canada, Mexico and the United States -- from taking
effect in January.
The new phase of liberalization entails the complete
elimination of tariffs on 21 farm products, including potatoes,
wheat, apples, onions, coffee, chicken and veal.
The NAFTA mechanism, which UNORCA describes as ''toxic to the
Mexican countryside,'' establishes three steps towards liberalizing
the farm and livestock sector. The first occurred in 1994 when the
three-nation treaty entered into force, the second is slated for
January, and the third in 2008.
In 1993, when NAFTA was still being negotiated, the government
of Carlos Salinas, then president of Mexico (1988-1994), agreed to
the process of a gradual elimination of agricultural tariffs with
the support of the country's leading farm organizations.
Now, nearly a decade later, they are all complaining.
Recognizing the difficulties that Mexican farmers face with
the deepening of trade liberalization, President Vicente Fox
announced in November that the government would provide support for
rural producers to the tune of 10 billion dollars in 2003, or 7.7
percent more aid than this year.
Fox stated last month that he is very concerned about how the
trade liberalization process is unfolding, ''in light of the U.S.
subsidies to its agricultural production.''
He said he would take up the matter with the George W. Bush
administration, but there has not been any indication of action so
far.
The Mexican president's aim would be to press the United
States to eliminate its farm subsidies, which total 19 billion
dollars a year, nearly double what Mexico has budgeted for its
farmers in 2003.
But Washington announced that it will not alter its farm
subsidy policies and that the situation of the Mexican farmers does
not justify annulment of the agricultural chapter of NAFTA.
Mexico would not ask for a suspension of the trade agreement's
farm provisions anyway, say Fox administration sources, because
doing so would mean revoking the country's recognition of the treaty
itself.
Since NAFTA took effect, Mexico's overall exports shot up from
60.9 billion dollars in 1994 to 158.4 billion dollars in 2001. In
that same period, imports jumped from 79.3 billion dollars to 168.4
billion dollars annually.
More than 85 percent of Mexican trade is currently
concentrated in exchange with the United States.
But for Mexico's rural areas, where 75 percent of the
population living in extreme poverty is concentrated, the three-
country treaty has meant the loss of more than 10 million hectares
of cultivated land.
And the decline of the rural sector has pushed 15 million
peasants -- and mostly young people -- to move to the cities, either
in Mexico or in the United States, according to a study by the
Autonomous National University of Mexico (UNAM).
Over the last 10 years, the participation of the farming
sector in Mexico's gross domestic product (GDP) has fallen from 7.3
percent to less than 5.0 percent.
The protests Tuesday echoed similar demonstrations in
November, including the blockade of a main federal highway by
farmers in the state of Morelos, neighboring the Mexico City federal
district, and protests by peasants from the southern states of
Oaxaca and Guerrero outside government offices in the capital.
The common denominator of all of these events is the rural
producers' rejection of NAFTA.
''The farmers are walking towards death because they are up
against the 'disloyal' trade competition from the United States and
the Mexican government's desertion of the countryside,'' says
Alberto Gsmez, UNORCA executive coordinator.
Without exception, Mexico's farmer organizations believe the
new phase of NAFTA-stipulated farm trade liberalization will
generate more poverty and prompt more people to leave rural areas.
They also reckon that the financial support Fox has promised
will not be nearly enough.
Mariano Ruiz, an analyst with the Mexico City-based Grupo de
Economistas y Asociados, says the worst blow for the Mexican farmers
will come in 2008 when the agricultural tariffs on products like
maize and beans are lifted.
An estimated 2.8 million Mexican farm families make their
livelihood from these commodities.
''The countryside is a time-bomb that could explode very
soon,'' commented Rosario Robles, chairwoman of the leftist
Democratic Revolutionary Party (PRD), the country's third political
force.
The elderly farmer Martmnez, who joined his colleagues for the
Mexico City march Tuesday, does not believe in anything that the Fox
government is offering.
''I have heard many things in the two years since he took
office. The one thing for certain is that I am getting poorer and
poorer,'' he said.
FROM: http://www.globalexchange.org/campaigns/ftaa/487.html
|
| Bull World Health Organ. 1999;77(5):375-80. |
|
Seasonal diarrhoeal mortality among Mexican
children.
Villa S, Guiscafre H, Martinez H, Munoz O, Gutierrez G.
Mexican Social Security Institute, Secretariat for Health,
Mexico City, Mexico.
The study investigated the effects on diarrhoeal deaths among
under-5-year-old Mexican children of the following variables:
season (summer or winter), region (north versus south), age group,
and place of death. Examination of death certificates indicated
that the distribution of deaths in 1989-90 was bimodal, with one
peak during the winter and a more pronounced one during the
summer. In 1993-94, however, the winter peak was higher than that
in the summer (odds ratio (OR) = 2.04). These findings were due
mostly to deaths among children aged 1-23 months (OR = 1.86).
Diarrhoeal mortality was highest among children aged 6-11 months
(OR = 2.23). During the winter, there was a significant increase
in the number of deaths that occurred in medical care units and
among children who had been seen by a physician before they died,
but deaths occurring at home showed no seasonal variation. In the
northern states, the reduction in diarrhoeal mortality was less in
winter than in summer (OR = 2.62). In the southern states, the
proportional reduction during the winter was similar to that in
the summer.
PIP: In this study, the influence of season, region, age group,
and place of occurrence of death on diarrheal mortality among
under-five Mexican children was examined. Data on diarrheal deaths
from 1989 to 1995 were collected from the National Institute of
Statistics, Geography and Information, Mexico City. All diarrheal
deaths among under-fives were identified by month to determine
whether there was any seasonal pattern. Results showed that the
distribution of death in 1989-90 was bimodal, with one peak during
the winter and a more pronounced one during the summer. However,
in 1993-94, the winter peak was higher than that in summer [odds
ratio (OR) = 2.04]. This was caused mostly by deaths among
children aged 1-23 months (OR = 1.86). Diarrheal mortality was
highest among children aged 6-11 months (OR = 2.23). A significant
increase in the number of deaths occurred during winter in medical
care units, but deaths occurring at home showed no seasonal
variation. The reduction in diarrheal mortality in northern states
was less pronounced in winter than in summer (OR = 2.62); however,
in the southern states, the proportional reduction in winter was
similar to that in summer.
FROM: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&list_uids=10361753&dopt=
Abstract
|
|
Wednesday, December 11, 2002
U.S. hospitals along Mexican border say illegal
immigrants are costing them big money
By Lynn Brezcsky
Associated Press Writer
BROWNSVILLE, Texas -- Ambulances regularly race across
the bridges of the Rio Grande, bringing some of Mexico's
sickest to the nearest U.S. emergency room.
Obligated by federal law, the hospitals provide the
care and worry later about whether the billing addresses
patients give them are accurate. Often the addresses are
false -- and the hospitals get stuck with the bill.
Immigrant patients have inflated medical expenses for
insurance companies, Medicaid and paying customers,
officials say, and are overwhelming already busy
hospitals in one of nation's fastest-growing regions.
One recent study by the U.S.-Mexico Border Counties
Coalition, an American lobbying group, found U.S. border
hospitals provided at least $200 million a year in
uncompensated emergency care to illegal immigrants, $74
million of that in Texas.
''Shh, don't tell Iowa farmers that part of their
taxes are paying for trauma that occurs south of the
border,'' Dr. Lorenzo Pelly, a south Texas doctor, told
state lawmakers at a recent hearing.
Republican state Sen. Chris Harris said he was
shocked by what he called the ''dumping'' of Mexicans on
U.S. hospitals.
Policymakers are just being to assess the size of the
problem.
Brownsville Medical Center estimates losses averaging
at least $500,000 per month. At Thomason Hospital in El
Paso, officials said their first attempt to estimate the
cost found $1 million over just three months.
Thomason Hospital responded by retaining a Mexican
lawyer and requiring patients to sign ''pagares,'' or
promissory notes, that carry weight under Mexican law.
It also signed on with a firm that specializes in
collecting past due accounts in Mexico.
Even without the influx from Mexico, U.S. border
hospitals are straining to meet the region's growing
medical needs. Some have resorted to importing doctors
and offering nurses tuition grants and signing bonuses.
But the load really jumped as Mexicans looking for
work stream to factories along the border. The North
American Free Trade Agreement has stimulated business on
both sides of the border, but hospitals have not kept
up.
NAFTA ''lacks the social economic infrastructure and
capacity'' to address the growth, said Eva Moya of the
Mexico Border Health Commission, made up of U.S. and
Mexican officials.
For the sick or injured on the Mexican side of the
border, the choice in a life-or-death situation can be a
three-hour journey inland to Monterrey, Mexico, or a
minutes-long trip to Brownsville, Laredo or El Paso.
The issue drew attention in September, when
4-year-old Larissa Guajardo, a U.S. citizen, died of
heart problems after crossing the Hidalgo-Reynosa
international bridge on the way to a hospital. Family
members blamed a delay caused by immigration officials,
who would not let the mother enter the country. The
mother lacked paperwork and had crossed the border
illegally before.
The Immigration and Naturalization Service said the
inspection process took only a few minutes and that
inspectors did not know the girl's illness was critical.
Once the seriousness was discovered, the mother was
allowed to enter on humanitarian grounds, the INS said.
The Sept. 11 attacks have also complicated the
situation along the border, with some authorities
worrying about what the ambulances might be holding.
''It is a security threat if they are going across
the border unchallenged, but at the same time, we don't
want to interfere with an emergency procedure,'' said
Carl Rusnok of the INS in Dallas.
The B&M International Bridge, which links
Brownsville with Matamoros, Mexico, has emergency
crossings down to a science, said Joe Galvan, president
of the company that runs it. The company has its own
security guards staffing both sides of the crossing, and
in medical emergencies a call goes out for the U.S. side
to clear a lane for fast passage.
Under a 1986 federal law, U.S. hospitals must treat
anyone who seeks emergency care, without regard to
immigration status or ability to pay. The government
gives hospitals extra funding to help poorer regions
absorb the costs of unreimbursed care, but hospitals say
it is not enough.
''This becomes a particular philosophical question
that these doctors are having,'' said Dominic Dominguez,
an administrator at Brownsville Medical Center. ''Part
of my signing to serve in this community is, I'll cover
this emergency room. But I didn't sign on to cover
Mexico.''
• • •
On the Net:
Border health commission: http://www.borderhealth.gov
Border counties coalition: http://www.bordercounties.org
|
|
|
|
STATISTICS
IN MEXICO
60.2% of people living with AIDS in Mexico
don't have access to Social Security services, from these, only 3.5%
gets attention at private institutions. Source: "Costs and
expenses of AIDS medical attention in Mexico" by Jorge Saavedra,
M.D. and Carlos Magis, M. D.
"Also, through informative campaigns and
with the support of health workers, we have started prevention
programs of new diseases affecting society, like the sad and dramatic
case of AIDS. It is encouraging to confirm that the AIDS
campaign, with great social support, has allowed to break down
the growth rate of this terrible illness, in particular during these
last three years. Nevertheless, we must say, the problem still
remains serious for the amount of infected people who don't even know
they are. That's why, I reiterate, that not only we'll mantain
but we'll also reinforce the AIDS campaign, because prevention keeps
being the only realistic alternative that we have against what is
known as the "Disease of the Century" and, of course, we'll
keep doing the best possible effort to assist to whom sadly are
already suffering the cruel illness, the compromise of the
Government of the Republic with the health of all mexicans and
specially our young ones, who are in major risk of infection,
it's unrefusable and it doesn't admit backing outs." Dr.
Ernesto Zedillo. President of Mexico. Fragment of the speach in
the Day of the Doctor, october 23rd.
The Conjoint Program of the United Nations on
HIV/AIDS (UNAIDS) has decided, along with its sponsors and associates,
to center the 1998 World Campaign Against AIDS on young people.
Among the main reasons of this decision are the following: More
than 50% of the new HIV infections, the virus which causes AIDS, are
actually produced in young people in the age group from 10 to 24
years. Young people are specially vulnerable to HIV infection
and are resulting seriously affected by the epidemic. Young
people hav the ability to modify the course of the epidemic.
This population group is not only infected and affected by
HIV/AIDS, but it's the key resource to mobilize a wide and efficient
response. UNAIDS.
In Mexico, the poorest 20% of population
gathers only 4.2% of the total income of the country, while the
wealthiest 20% has 55% of the national income. In 1995, the
fortune of the wealthiest mexican citizen was equivalent to the income
of 17 million of the poorest mexicans all together. Dr. Peter
Piot, Executive Director of UNAIDS.
"In Latinamerica, we estimate that in
1997, 160 thousand people were infected by HIV, which is equivalent to
approximately to the number of people that got infected in the same
year in Europe and Northamerica together." Dr. Peter Piot,
Executive Director of UNAIDS.
"Everyday, 16 thousand people get
infected by HIV in the world. 75% of new AIDS cases are by
sexual relations. Seven thousand are young people between
the ages of 10 and 24, which means that every minute 5 youngsters get
infected." Sally Cowel, UNAIDS Foreign Relations Secretary.
By year 2000, we'll all know someone with
AIDS, it can be a friend, a work or school partner, a relative or
maybe ourselves. World Health Organization.
"AIDS is the most complex public
health program of the country." Dr. Juan Ramón de la Fuente,
Health Secretary.
Drug approvals are faster every time, yet not
fast enough.
This year's slogan of the AIDS Campaign will
be:
"It's in the man's hands to change the course of the AIDS
epidemic."
"I reiterate that the government of the
Republic will not back off in the presence of any kind of pressure
against public campaigns of family planification and AIDS
prevention." Dr. Ernesto Zedillo, former President of Mexico.
In 1988, in the age group from 25 to 34, AIDS
was the 18th cause of death, while in 1992 it already had taken the
5th place. Among men, AIDS as a cause of death went from the
11th to the 4th place in 1991. In 1998 AIDS didn't appear within
the first 20 causes of death in the women's group, but in 1992 it
already had the 12th place. "Public Health in Mexico"
- "Salud Pública de México" publication, from march/april
of 1996, page 143. J. A. Izazola, M. García Valdez, H. J. Sánchez
P., C. del Rio Chiriboga.
In Mexico, AIDS is the third cause of death
at a national level among men in the ages from 25 to 24, and the sixth
among women in that same age. General Office of Statistics and
Computing of the Health Sector.
Every day, 16 thousand people contract HIV,
from which, 7 thousand are in the age range from 10 to 24, which means
that each minute 5 youngsters get infected. To date, 30 million
600 thousand have gotten infected. 90% of the AIDS cases are in
third world countries. UNAIDS.
It is estimated that up to december 1997, the
number of infected people worldwide is of 30.6 million of people,
which almost doubles the estimated by experts a few years ago.
During 1997 in all the world, more than 590 thousand children acquired
the virus and it is estimated that from here to year 2010 there will
be 42 million orphan children because of AIDS. UNAIDS.
According to the prevailing cases of AIDS,
not the number, Mexico takes the 69th place worldwide and the 29th in
Latinamerica and the Caribbean. CONASIDA.
According to a publication in the Reforma
newspaper, in Mexico City everyday are committed 12 sexual crimes, 90%
on women and 10% in men.
In public hospitals of the Federal District,
every year are given 29 million of doctor appointments, including the
Mexican Institute of Social Security, the Institute of Social Security
to the Service of Government Workers, Armed Forces, Mexican Oil,
health centers and Hospitals of the Federal District Department, from
which 21 million are given to health benificiaries and the rest to the
open public, according to data given by the director of the Health
Institute of the Federal District. Manuel Ruiz de Chávez.
During 1996, a health budget for $10 thousand
641 million pesos was exercised. The budget for 1997 was of $18
thousand 421 million pesos.
Budget programmed for the branch 23 during
1996 was of $31 thousand 499 million pesos, from which only $6
thousand 640 million of pesos was exercised. For 1997 the budget
was of $38 thousand 339 million pesos, more than the double of what
was destined for health. Data published by the Reforma newspaper
on November 13th, 1997.
In the project of Budget of the Federation
for 1998, a health expense for $80 thousand million pesos is
considered. This proyect calculates to incorporate 600 thousand
additional people to the Wide Covering Program "PAC",
indicating that it will attend 6 million 600 thousand mexicans in
total with the Basic Packet of Health Services. PAC will cover
in 1998 to two thirds of the population that in 1994 didn't have
health services and lives in 600 of the poorest municipalities of the
country.
There are 56 etnias in our country; this
indigenous towns are formed by approximately 10 million of people,
according to data from the Government Office.
In the actuality, there are 94.7 million of
habitants in Mexico, if the expected population goals are met, for the
year 2000 there will be 100 million, for the year 2010 there will be
112 million and for the year 2030 there will be 131 million. The
national average age in which a woman gets married is at 20. In
the middle and high classes, the woman dedicates 10.5 years to the
raising of her children, which is the time that occurs from the birth
of her first child until the last one grows to be 6 years old; in the
poor class this period is of 25 years. Every year the population
grows in 1 million 400 thousand habitants, and there are needed 1
million of new jobs. It is calculated that each year between 100
thousand and 150 thousand abortions are practiced. Source:
National Council for Population - CONAPO.
In the last 20 years, birth rate in Mexico
has decreased to 50%, on the other hand, pregnancy among teenagers
under 20 doubled, giving the fifth part of births per year, which is
equivalent to 450 thousand pregnancies. 67% of pregnant minors
were born from teenager moms; only 17% of young couples use
contraceptive methods. According to UNICEF numbers, published in
the Reforma newspaper on March 15th, 1998, page 30.
In Mexico, 150 thousand women abort annually,
according to data from the National Council of Population - CONAPO.
But Non-Governmental Organizations, such as GIRE, estimate that they
are 850 thousand.
INEGI informs that the gross domestic product
from january to september, 1997, rised up to 396 billion 222.5
million dollars, which is equal to 4 thousand 182.70 per habitant.
According to information given by the SECOFI,
from january to august, 1997, foreign investment was of $5,543
millions of dollars, mainly from the United States of America.
Data published by the La Jornada newspaper,
shows that 40 million of mexicans live in poverty, 17 million in
extreme poverty. One of each five families doesn't get enough
income to buy the food required for the nutrition of its members.
One of each two mexicans in the field and one of each nine in the city
live in extreme poverty. In the Federal District there are 20
thousand street kids (13 thousand, according to the Human Rights
Commission of the Federal District), 13 thousand homeless adults attending
424 shelters, 446 thousand indigenous people who earn less than
minimum wage and 590 thousand elders who live from charity.
40 million of mexicans show malnutrition
problems; of these 17.7 million live in urban zones and 22.3 million
live in rural zones. Information given by Foodfirst Information
and Action Network on the World Feeding Day.
According to the annual report "World
state of childhood" of the United Nations Fund for the Children -
UNICEF, in rural zones of Mexico, 58% of children under the age of 5
show physical and mental deficiencies due to malnutrition. The
normal intelectual coefficient of 100, sees itself diminished by 10%
and stature by 5 inches. According to a study conducted by
Securities Action Capital, published in the newspaper La Jornada last
december 9th, the delay index of commerce debtors in our country, went
from 13.1% of the total credit portfolio in december of 1994, to 45.4%
in 1995, to 49% in 1996 and to 53.1% in september 1997.
The Human Development Report of 1998, made by
the United Nations, and spreaded by its Development Program of the
United Nations - PNUD, on september 9th of 1998, considers that
14.9% of mexicans survive with a dollar a day.
Mexico has a human poverty index - IPX - of
10.7%, which means that this percentage of population is excluded in
base of three essential elements: longevity, knowledge and quality of
life.
This index, in which Mexico takes the 49th
place worldwide, considers life expectancy, access to education and
the real income level.
8% of mexicans won't live to be 40, 17% of
population don't have access to drinkable water, 7% don't have any
kind of health services and 28% don't have sanitation services.
Only 66% of population between the ages of 6
and 23 has access to education. In 1980 this percentage of 68%,
in other words, the number has decreased against what was expected.
Up to here the report of PNUD.
In our country, there are 9 million of people
with some kind of disability.
Programs of banking rescue will channel
fiscal funds way over 77 thousand, 400 million pesos ending 1977;
while the following portfolio sales to the Bank Fund for the Savings
Protection "FOBAPROA" got to 236 thousand 220.6 million
pesos to the end of the first semester, equivalent to 28 thousand
million one hundred and twenty one thousand five hundred dollars.
It is estimated that at the end of december
of 1997 there are about 13,500 people living with AIDS, from which 50%
don't have access to social security, and their individual treatment
cost would go up to 84 thousand pesos a year at least, equivalent to
10 thousand dollars, for a total of 6,750 people of $ 67 million 500
thousand dollars, which is what FONSIDA expects to raise.
According to studies published by two of the
most important diaries in Germany and reproduced by the Reforma
newspaper, referring to the problems what the new government of the
city of Mexico will have to face, say that "the indifferent and
inefficient attitude of the police, that only gets to solve 2% of the
total of reported crime, against 20% in New York, 30% in London and up
to 60% in some german cities".
In the United States of America, 74 million
of people have used some kind of illegal drug at a specific moment in
their lives. There are 13 millon of frequent consumers of
illegal subtances in this country. Main illegal drugs being
consumed are: marihuana, cocaine, crack, LSD and heroine. A
great number of americans begin cosuming drugs at the age of 12.
According to data from the National Office for Drug Control of the
White House of the United States of America, AIDS is an illness
frequentl associated with illegal drug consuming in the United
States of America.
"Halt on the development of an AIDS
vaccine, violates all the ethic principles and human rights".
Jonathan M. Mann.
Predictions say that there will be 100
million of people living with HIV/AIDS for the year 2007. UNAIDS.
Governments from each country should consider
fight against AIDS as the main priority in the national agenda.
Mrs. Ruth Cardoso. First lady of Brasil.
In Mexico, there are 60 million of people
living in poverty, from which, 20 million are in extreme poverty,
surviving with less than $2.00 dollars a day. Report from the
World Bank.
In our country, there are 9 million people
with some kind of disability.
FROM: http://www.aids-sida.org/_statistics05.html
|
| A
border incident
FROM
LEBANON TO MEXICO??
Terence
Jeffrey (back
to web version)
June
25, 2003
When Border Patrol officials in San Diego learned last June
about circumstances surrounding a dead body deposited at the county
medical examiner's office, they sent over an agent with a radiation
detector.
"It was an out-of-the-ordinary situation, where you had an
individual from the Middle East who was found along our border,"
said Raleigh Leonard, spokesman for the Border Patrol's San Diego
sector. The man had been dropped off at a local hospital, Leonard told
me, "by people who said that he had crossed illegally into the
United States and was subsequently found . . . throwing up
blood."
He was 21-year-old Youseff Balaghi. He had come from faraway
Lebanon to the border near Tijuana.
"He was suffering from some very serious illness that no
one at that particular time could identify," said Leonard.
"He died. He was turned over to the San Diego County Medical
Examiner's office. They called us."
"We did not perform an autopsy," said Dr. Jonathan
Lucas, deputy medical examiner for San Diego County. The man's family,
Lucas told me, refused consent for the procedure on religious grounds,
but blood and urine samples were drawn for standard toxicology tests.
These showed nothing particularly unusual, and the cause of death was
listed as "undetermined."
By the time the Border Patrol arrived with its radiation
detector, the body was gone but the blood and urine samples remained.
"At that time," said Leonard, "many of us were
looking into information regarding dirty bombs.
"We had been studying and attending classes ever since
September 11th in regards to terrorist-related activity so we are very
keen on terrorist-type weapons, tactics, dirty bombs, different
behavioral patterns, but also some of the sicknesses that are
attributed to radiation poisoning," he said.
Fortunately, the detector showed Balaghi was clean.
That's the good news.
The bad news: Balaghi wasn't the only Middle Eastern illegal who
slipped across our Mexican border.
Salim Boughader-Mucharrafille, a Tijuana restaurateur, conducted
a regular business running Middle Easterners into California.
Last December, U.S. Attorney Carol C. Lam of San Diego unsealed
an indictment charging Boughader, a Mexican citizen, and two other
Mexicans, Patricia Serrano-Valdez and Jose Alvarez Duenas, with alien
smuggling.
An affidavit filed in federal court by Senior Border Patrol
Agent John R. Korkin said an investigation "positively identified
at least 80 Lebanese nationals that have been, or were in the process
of being, smuggled into the U.S. from November 19, 1999 to the present
by a smuggling organization of affiliated individuals headed and
coordinated by Boughader."
Boughader, Serrano and Duenas all cut plea bargains. Assistant
U.S. Attorney Mike Skerlos, who prosecuted the case, said Serrano ran
a safe house for Boughader in San Diego and Duenas was a
"coyote" who guided aliens across the border. Boughader,
Skerlos said, admitted in court to smuggling more than 100 people.
Neither Serrano nor Duenas, he said, were involved in the incident
that resulted in the death of Balaghi, but Boughader pleaded guilty in
Balaghi's case to smuggling an alien "resulting in death."
I asked Skerlos whether any of the Middle Easterners smuggled by
Boughader had ties to terrorist organizations. "No comment,"
he said.
Boughader's organization, said Korkin's affidavit, "employs
several individuals and co-conspirators in various countries including
Lebanon."
As a result of his plea bargain, Boughader will serve only one
year and one day in prison. Hopefully, he has been induced to help
investigators track his clients.
Since December, the San Diego Union-Tribune has run two reports
revealing that Balaghi's remains were tested for radiation.
I asked Leonard how often the Border Patrol in his sector
intercepts Middle Eastern illegals. "It happens," he said.
"It's not by any means unusual. But it isn't every day."
"Radiation detectors," he also told me, "are
being issued out to the Border Patrol agents. We are in the process of
putting together a standard operations procedure packet, telling
agents how to operate them . . . how they will be used, where they
will be used. As soon as that is completed the devices will be issued
out to the agents, absolutely.
"Just one more thing," said Leonard. "We're out
there securing and protecting our nation's borders, and we take these
terrorist and terrorist-related threats very seriously, and we're
working hard to protect and secure our nation's borders."
That's a certainty. Law enforcement in San Diego -- from the
Border Patrol, to the federal prosecutors to the county medical
examiner -- are doing their best. But as long as Middle Eastern aliens
keep sneaking in from Mexico, it is an equal certainty these officers
are not getting all the support they need from policymakers in
Washington.
FROM; http://www.townhall.com/columnists/terencejeffrey/printtj20030625.shtml
|
TRUCK TRAILER BECOMES A COFFIN
Source: PAULINE ARRILLAGA Associated Press
DALLAS --- It was midafternoon by the time the big
rig rolled into Love's truck stop off I-20 in Dallas. As soon as the
drivers climbed out, they heard fists pounding on the inside of the
trailer walls.Jason Sprague lifted the latch. The cargo doors flew
wide.More than 40 illegal immigrants --- packed into the unventilated
cargo compartment 12 hours earlier --- came tumbling out.A woman,
sobbing, hurled her fists at Sprague's co-driver, Troy Dock. Others,
unable to move,
Published on May 25, 2004, Page A1, Columbus Ledger-Enquirer (GA)
Mexico call over migrant deaths
Mexico says the deaths of 18 suspected illegal immigrants
who suffocated inside a trailer in Texas shows the need to
legalise the migration of workers across the US border.
A Mexican foreign ministry statement condemned what it called
"this lamentable incident" and promised co-operation
with the US in tackling immigrant trafficking.
The grim discovery of the bodies at a rest stop in Texas was
one of the worst cases of people smuggling in the border area in
recent years.
Survivors have been speaking of their desperation as they
struggled to escape from the back of the tractor-trailer where
it is believed up to 100 people were crammed.
One person inside the sweltering container used a mobile
phone to make an emergency call, pleading in Spanish for help as
people suffocated.
But the call could not be traced.
Police eventually found the trailer at a truck rest stop near
the city of Victoria, about 370 kilometres (230 miles) from the
Mexican border early on Wednesday.
The victims - many of them Mexicans but some from Central
America - appeared to have died from suffocation and heat
exhaustion, US officials said.
Desperation
Some of the 39 survivors in US custody have told Mexican
consular officials that smugglers loaded them onto the trailer
on Tuesday and the air conditioning inside at first worked well.
But when the driver unhooked his cab and abandoned the
trailer some hours later, it soon became airless.
"In desperation, the people said they broke out the
truck's taillights to try and attract someone's attention and
perhaps get some air," Marco Nunez of the Mexican consul's
office in Houston told AP.
Some of the victims were said to have torn off their clothes
because of the heat.
Police have arrested the trailer's registered owner and are
were still looking for two other people, US officials said.
The authorities also believe 40 illegal immigrants who
tumbled out of the vehicle alive when it was opened managed to
escape.
The Mexican Government has long pressed Washington to make it
easier for Mexicans to come to the US legally.
Every year thousands of Latin Americans make the hazardous
journey and are often at the mercy of smuggling gangs.
"This lamentable incident shows the need for and
importance of achieving safe conditions on the border for
migrants and the need for safe, legal and orderly
migration," the foreign ministry statement read.
"The Mexican Government reiterates its commitment to
fight gangs of immigrant traffickers and those who seek to
profit at the expense of undocumented migrants."
DOORS TO DEATH: PART 1
Source: Associated Press
CHAPARRAL, N.M. --- The 18-wheeler pulled off the
desert highway and rumbled down a pockmarked clay road, its headlights
raking a desolate hamlet of double-wides. The big rig, making an
unscheduled detour at the start of a midnight run from El Paso to
Dallas, slowed as it approached a dingy mobile home. Then the
headlights snapped off. It turned through a gap in a chain-link fence
and backed in close to the house. Jason Sprague climbed down from the
cab and swung open the trailer's
Published on May 24, 2004, Page A1, Columbus Ledger-Enquirer (GA)
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
MIGRANT FOES
Source: Associated Press
FRESNO, Calif. --- President Bush's plan to give
undocumented workers temporary legal status brings back painful
memories for Florentino Lararios, who spent 14 grueling years in a
similar World War II-era program. Lararios, a 77-year-old with large,
rough hands that never mastered a pencil, recalls the back-breaking
work picking cotton in the South, the slapped-together communal
housing, the cold meals eaten in the fields, and the unwelcome
prospect of going back to Mexico without a
Published on January 14, 2004, Page C7, Columbus Ledger-Enquirer (GA)
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
BUSH PLANS TO HELP ILLEGALS
Source: Associated Press
WASHINGTON --- Promoting a plan that could brighten
his election-year prospects with Hispanic voters, President Bush on
Wednesday proposed legal status --- at least temporarily --- for
millions of illegal immigrants working in the United States. But the
sweeping policy overhaul, offered with few specifics, also angered
many in the president's conservative Republican base of support and
drew criticism from advocacy groups who questioned whether it would do
much to help
Published on January 8, 2004, Page A1, Columbus Ledger-Enquirer (GA)
|
- Jose Latour's Port of Entry Daily Column -
Guys, today's article is based on some research that Cynthia,
"my shiny, brilliant new assistant," dug up on MSNBC.
The information is a little grim, it is very compelling and, I'm afraid,
it is indicative of where our national immigration policy seems to be
headed.
Let's start off with a sobering fact: according to the statistics
kept by the Mexican government, here's a look at the fatalities of Mexicans
on the border for the past five years:
1997 - 129 deaths
1998 - 297 deaths
1999 - 358 deaths
2000 - 455 deaths
2001 (through Sept. of that year, the latest statistics available) -
303 deaths
While the 2001 statistic indicates a comparative reduction in
border deaths
when contrasted with the prior year, the overall pattern is clear: more Mexicans
are dying on the border. Why?
According to MSNBC and various other sources we've researched,
human rights groups are blaming increased enforcement by the U.S. Border
Patrol as a primary reason. But how exactly does a nation's protection
of its own border cause the deaths
of those seeking to unlawfully enter the country? Moreover, does a
nation's sovereign right to control entry onto its own soil carry with
it extraordinary responsibilities designed to ensure that, in their
desperation, the would-be illegal
migrants do not risk life and limb to circumvent the deterrents to their
entry?
In 1994, the U.S. Border Patrol launched Operation "Gate
Keeper" at the border near San Diego, where the majority of illegal
Mexican entries into the United States occur. The operation has resulted
in increased manpower, expanded fencing, intensified lighting, and
amplified monitoring via underground sensors designed to sense the
movement of individuals across the ground. These enforcement tools have
resulted in the migrants seeking to cross more difficult terrain to
enter the United States. Accordingly, by crossing through more difficult
parts of the desert and by the traversing of the Rio Grande, the major
causes of death among would-be migrants are drowning and heatstroke
according to the California Rural Assistance Foundation.
Now, I have to be careful how I ask this question, but I must ask
it:
How can human rights groups blame the U.S. government
for the deaths
of these individuals when the only thing that the U.S. government has
done is increase enforcement, completely appropriate with national
sovereignty laws?
In other words, if the U.S. government has a responsibility to
leave open easy routes for illegal
migration into the United States, we are essentially asking the federal
government to give up its sovereign right. By blaming the federal
government for these deaths,
human rights groups are essentially placing the responsibility for the
motivation of illegal
migration on the U.S. government, and I respectfully submit to you that
is not fair. A cause and effect explanation of the deaths,
yes, absolutely! But to blame the U.S. Border Patrol is simply
unconscionable.
No sir, the fault for these tragic deaths
in the desert and through drowning lies squarely on the groups of
cowardly "coyotes," the weasel alien smugglers who take the
big bucks to violate our federal laws. They are the primary
parties responsible for these tragic deaths.
Secondly, as politically incorrect as it is, the second
most responsible parties are the individuals themselves who embark upon
these journeys to make an illegal
entry. (Yes, I see the tomatoes flying. I understand that these
individuals are desperate and seeking new lives in the United States. I
further understand that they come from impoverished countries and are
seeking better lives, but I also understand that these individuals are
consciously making the decision to enter illegally into another
country in defiance of that country's laws and, as adult human beings,
are making calculated decisions in doing so. For human rights
organizations to blame the Border Patrol for the death of an individual
who has made such a decision is simply to place blame on the wrong
party. Free will exists in these situations.)
Okay, enough with the tomatoes.
In the MSNBC report much is made of the fact that Mr. Bush was
courting Mexico's President Fox with vague promises of some sort of
amnesty to resolve the status of the estimated three million illegal
Mexicans
residing in the United States. After September 11, the notion of amnesty
for illegal
aliens seems as elusive as peace in the Middle East. But consider these
numbers and you will understand the nature of the issue:
-
From 1901 - 1970, approximately 1.5 million Mexicans
immigrated legally to the United States.
-
From 1981 - 1990, less than nine years, more than 1.6 million Mexicans
did the same thing.
-
From 1991 - 1998, 1.9 million immigrated legally.
It is evident that the number of Mexicans
immigrating legally to the United States is certainly not decreasing.
The number immigrating illegally is equally on the rise.
In fiscal year 2000, from October 1, 2000 until September 30,
2001, the U.S. Border Patrol apprehended 1,643,679 illegal
aliens along the border. The largest increase, according to MSNBC, has
been in Arizona while there was a decline along the California border,
historically the busiest entry point for illegal
aliens into the U.S.
What does all this mean for the rest of us who are not from Mexico
but who are concerned about immigration policy? It's hard to tell right
now, but these are the questions that must be answered in the coming
months and years:
-
How will the U.S. formulate an immigration policy that gives
Mexico the special treatment she deserves as our southern neighbor
with very unique immigration needs?
-
How will the U.S. formulate an ongoing evolution of trade
policy addressing the reality that Mexico's illegal
immigration stems almost solely from economic need, not cultural
preference?
FROM: http://66.102.7.104/search?q=cache:tLXlFs4TmLEJ:www.usvisanews.com/memo1727.html+illegal+mexicans+
deaths&hl=en
|
Summary
About 5.0 million undocumented
immigrants were residing in the United States in October 1996, with a
range of about 4.6 to 5.4 million .
The population was estimated to be growing by about 275,000 each year,
which is about 25,000 lower than the annual level of growth estimated by
the INS in 1994.
California is the leading state of
residence, with 2.0 million, or 40 percent of the undocumented
population. The 7 states with the largest estimated numbers of
undocumented immigrants--California (2.0 million), Texas (700,000), New
York (540,000), Florida (350,000), Illinois (290,000), New Jersey
(135,000), and Arizona (115,000)--accounted for 83 percent of the total
population in October 1996.
The 5.0 million undocumented
immigrants made up about 1.9 percent of the total U.S. population, with
the highest percentages in California, the District of Columbia, and
Texas. In the majority of states, undocumented residents comprise less
than 1 percent of the population.
Mexico is the leading country of
origin, with 2.7 million, or 54 percent, of the population. The Mexican
undocumented population has grown at an average annual level of just
over 150,000 since 1988. The 15 countries with 50,000 or more
undocumented immigrants in 1996 accounted for 82 percent of the total
population. The large majority, over 80 percent, of all undocumented
immigrants are from countries in the Western Hemisphere.
About 2.1 million, or 41 percent, of
the total undocumented population in 1996 are nonimmigrant overstays.
That is, they entered legally on a temporary basis and failed to depart.
The proportion of the undocumented population who are overstays varies
considerably by country of origin. About 16 percent of the Mexican
undocumented population are nonimmigrant overstays, compared to 26
percent of those from Central America, and 91 percent from all other
countries.
Background
In 1994 the INS released detailed
estimates of the undocumented immigrant population residing in the
United States as of October 1992. Those estimates were useful for a
variety of purposes, including planning and policy development at the
national and state level, evaluating the effects of proposed
legislation, and assessing the fiscal impacts of undocumented
immigration.
Over the past 2 years, the INS has
revised those estimates and updated them to October 1996. The estimates
presented here incorporate new data on the foreign-born population
collected by the Census Bureau, improvements in the methodology
recommended by the General Accounting Office (GAO), suggestions provided
by outside reviewers, and further analyses of INS' data sources and
estimation procedures. Revised and updated estimates of the undocumented
population have been computed for each state of residence and for nearly
100 countries of origin.
Methodology
The estimates were constructed by
combining detailed statistics, by year of entry, for each component of
change that contributes to the undocumented immigrant population
residing in the United States. For most countries of the world, the
typical way of entering the undocumented population in the United States
is to arrive as a nonimmigrant and stay beyond the specified period of
admission. This segment of the population, referred to here as
"nonimmigrant overstays", constitutes roughly 40 percent of
the undocumented immigrant population residing in the United States. The
rest of the population, more widely publicized, enter surreptitiously
across land borders, usually between official ports of entry. This part
of the population, often referred to as EWIs (entry without inspection),
includes persons from nearly every country, but a large majority of them
are from Mexico; most of the rest are natives of Central American
countries.
Primary Sets of Data
The figures presented here were
constructed from five primary sets of data. Each set of data was
compiled separately for 99 countries and each continent of origin.
1) Entered before 1982--estimates (as
of October 1988) of the undocumented immigrant population who
established residence in the United States before 1982 and did not
legalize under the Immigration
Reform and Control Act (IRCA) of 1986. The assumption used to
estimate this part of the population is based on estimates developed by
the Census Bureau using data from the June 1988 Current Population
Survey (CPS).
2) Net overstays--estimates for 1982
to 1996 of the net number of nonimmigrant overstays, for 99 countries of
origin, derived from INS data bases. Estimates were derived by: a)
matching INS I-94 arrival/departure records; b) adjusting for the
incomplete collection of departure forms; and c) subtracting the number
of nonimmigrant overstays who subsequently either departed or adjusted
to legal resident status.
3) Net EWIs--estimates of the number
from each country who entered without inspection (EWI) and established
residence here between 1982 and 1996. A very large majority of all EWIs
are from Mexico. Average annual estimates of Mexican EWIs were derived
by: a) adjusting the CPS count of the Mexican-born population for
underenumeration; b) subtracting the estimated legally resident
population counted in the CPS; and c) subtracting the estimated number
of net overstays.
4) Mortality--estimates of the annual
number of deaths to the resident undocumented immigrant population. The
estimates were derived using an annual crude death rate of 3.9 per
1,000, which was computed using a modified age distribution of IRCA
applicants and age-specific death rates of the foreign-born population.
5) Emigration--estimates of the
number of undocumented immigrants who resided here at the beginning of a
period (either October 1988 or October 1992), and who emigrated from the
United States in the following 4-year period. Estimates of emigration
are based on statistics published by the Census
Bureau in Technical Paper No. 9.
Construction of the Estimates
Estimates of the undocumented
immigrant population were derived for October 1988, October 1992, and
October 1996 for 99 individual countries and for each continent of
origin. The calculations were carried out separately for overstays and
EWIs.
Estimates by State of Residence
In the earlier estimates for October
1992, the state distribution of the undocumented population was based on
the U.S. residence pattern of each country's applicants for legalization
under IRCA; the results were summed to obtain state totals. This assumed
that, for each country of origin, undocumented immigrants who resided in
the United States in October 1992 had the same U.S. residence pattern as
IRCA applicants from that country. The revised and updated estimates
presented here incorporate the same assumption for the October 1988
undocumented population. However, it was necessary to develop new
methods of deriving state estimates for October 1992 and 1996 that would
reflect more recent patterns of geographic settlement.
As noted, the estimates of the
undocumented population were constructed separately for overstays and
EWIs. This permitted the distribution of the overstay and EWI
populations to states using data most appropriate for the type of
population. For overstays, the cohorts that arrived in the 1988-92 and
1992-96 periods were distributed to state of residence based on annual
estimates of overstays by state of destination for 1986 to 1989. For
EWIs who entered during these periods, the totals were distributed to
state of residence using INS statistics for the early 1990s on the
destination of the beneficiaries of aliens who legalized under IRCA.
Limitations
Estimating the size of a hidden
population is inherently difficult. Overall, the figures presented here
generally reflect the size, origin, and geographic distribution of the
undocumented immigrant population residing in the United States during
the mid-1990s. The estimates probably reduce the range of error for the
total population to a few hundred thousand rather than a few million,
which was the error range during the late 1970s and into the 1980s. The
estimates for most countries should be fairly precise because they were
constructed primarily from data on nonimmigrant arrivals, departures,
and adjustments of status that have relatively small margins of error.
Although the estimates are based on
the most reliable information available, they clearly have limitations.
For example, the estimates make no allowance for students or other
long-term nonimmigrants, and the estimates for some countries could be
underestimated because of special circumstances (e.g., Dominicans
entering illegally via Puerto Rico; ships arriving undetected from
China).
The figures for some countries
overstate the actual undocumented population. In general, the net
nonimmigrant overstay figures are more likely to be overestimates than
underestimates because the collection of departure forms for long-term
overstays who depart probably is less complete than for those who depart
within the first year.
The estimates include a large number
of persons who have not been admitted for lawful permanent residence but
are permitted to remain in the United States pending the determination
of their status or until conditions improve in their country of origin.
This category includes many of the undocumented immigrants from El
Salvador, aliens from other countries in a status referred to as
"deferred enforced departure", and IRCA applicants whose cases
have not been finally resolved.
In a few cases, the estimates appear
to be too high, but we have no basis for making downward adjustments.
For example, the estimates for the Bahamas appear to be much too large
because they imply that a relatively large proportion of the population
is residing illegally in the United States, whereas large-scale
undocumented immigration from the Bahamas has not been observed
previously. In addition, undocumented immigration from Dominica is
considerably higher than would be expected based on the number of IRCA
applicants from Dominica. This overstatement could have occurred because
of processing problems with I-94 arrival/departure documents, with the
result that overstays from Dominica are overestimated and those from the
Dominican Republic underestimated.
The number of EWIs is the most
difficult component to estimate with precision, and errors in this
component have the largest effect on the estimated undocumented
population from Mexico. In particular, the shortage of information about
two components--emigration of legally resident immigrants and undercount
in the CPS--makes it difficult to derive acceptable residual estimates
of the number of undocumented immigrants counted in the CPS.
The estimates presented here are
based on the most extensive array of figures ever compiled for the
purpose; nevertheless, they should be used with caution because of the
inherent limitations in the data available for estimating the
undocumented immigrant population. This uncertainty was addressed by
using alternative assumptions to produce "high" and
"low" population estimates for October 1996. In the following
discussion of the estimates, the mid-range population figures are used
for simplicity of presentation.
Results
National Estimates
The total number of undocumented
immigrants residing in the United States in October 1996 is estimated to
be 5.0 million , with a range of about 4.6 to 5.4 million. The estimate
for October 1996 is about 1.1 million higher than the revised estimate
of 3.9 million for October 1992; this implies that the population grew
by about 275,000 annually during the 1992-96 period, about the same as
the annual growth of 281,000 estimated for the previous period. The
original INS estimates for October 1992 and October 1988, released in
1994, showed average annual growth of 300,000.
The undocumented population grows at
varying levels from year to year, but the data available to make these
estimates do not permit the derivation of annual figures to measure
year-to-year changes. However, the similar levels of growth for the
1988-92 and 1992-96 periods, 281,000 and 275,000, respectively, suggest
that the overall level of growth has been fairly constant over the past
decade. This also indicates that the rate of growth of the undocumented
resident population has declined since 1988.
State of Residence
The estimates for states reflect the
well-established pattern of geographic concentration of undocumented
immigrants in the United States. As expected, California was the leading
state of residence, with 2.0 million, or 40 percent, of the total number
of undocumented residents in October 1996. Seven states--California (2.0
million), Texas (700,000), New York (540,000), Florida (350,000),
Illinois (290,000), New Jersey (135,000), and Arizona
(115,000)--accounted for 83 percent of the population in October 1996.
The estimated undocumented population
of California has grown by an average of about 100,000 annually since
the end of the IRCA legalization program in 1988. More than 83 percent
of total growth of the undocumented population since 1988 has occurred
in the top seven states. With the exception of Massachusetts (6,000),
none of the remaining 43 states grew by more than 3,000 undocumented
residents annually. In 27 states, the undocumented population grew by an
average of 1,000 or less each year.
Country of Origin
Mexico is the leading source country
of undocumented immigration to the United States. In October 1996 an
estimated 2.7 million undocumented immigrants from Mexico had
established residence here . Mexican undocumented immigrants constituted
about 54 percent of the total undocumented population. The estimated
population from Mexico increased by just over 150,000 annually in both
the 1988-92 and 1992-96 periods.
The estimated number of Mexican
undocumented immigrants who arrived between 1990 and 1996 is based on
data on country of birth and year of immigration collected by the Census
Bureau in the March 1994, 1995, and 1996 Current
Population Surveys (CPS) Demographic analysis of the CPS data
indicates that approximately 230,000 undocumented Mexican immigrants
established residence annually between 1990 and 1996. This is the net
annual addition of undocumented Mexicans who arrived during the period.
Note, however, that it does not reflect the average annual growth of the
Mexican undocumented population. To compute average annual growth it is
necessary to subtract the number of undocumented Mexicans who lived here
in January 1990 and who emigrated, died, or adjusted to legal permanent
resident status during the 1990-96 period. This last step produces the
estimate cited above of just over 150,000 annual growth of the Mexican
undocumented population since 1988.
In October 1996, 15 countries were
each the source of 50,000 or more undocumented immigrants. The top five
countries are geographically close to the United states--Mexico, El
Salvador, Guatemala, Canada, and Haiti. Of the top 15 countries, only
the Philippines and Poland are outside the Western Hemisphere. The
estimated undocumented population from Poland has declined by more than
25 percent, from 95,000 to 70,000, since 1988, possibly reflecting
changed conditions in that country over the last several years.
Although undocumented immigrants come
to the United States from all countries the world, relatively few
countries add substantially to the population. The annual growth of the
undocumented population can be grouped into four disparate categories:
1) Mexico, with more than half of the annual growth, adds just over
150,000 undocumented residents each year; 2) six countries--El Salvador,
Guatemala, Canada, Haiti, Honduras, and the Bahamas--each add between
6,000 and 12,000 annually; 3) thirteen countries each add about 2,000 to
4,000 annually; and 4) the remaining approximately 200 other countries
add a total of about 30,000 undocumented residents each year . A large
majority of the additions each year, more than 80 percent, are from
countries in the Western Hemisphere.
FROM: http://uscis.gov/graphics/shared/aboutus/statistics/illegalalien/
|
Silver Lake Gang War
Homeboys and hipsters struggle to claim Silver Lake by Christine Pelisek
Oct 10-16, 2003
On a recent afternoon a Latino woman and her son wearily shuffle
past a makeshift shrine in front of a shabby apartment complex on the
700 block of Vendome Street. The shrine, nearly obscured by a discarded
mattress and other litter, is dedicated to Valentin Rangel, a member of
the Silver Lake 13 gang. He died there in a hail of bullets over Labor
Day weekend, two months shy of his 26th birthday. A half-dozen Mexican
religious candles, a few still burning, decorate the scene. A photo of a
smiling Rangel is propped up next to them. Scattered alongside the photo
are personal mementos . two skateboarding magazines, a pair of black
sunglasses and a Holy Bible. .RIP Val. is spray-painted on the street in
front of the memorial. Across the street, on the corner of Vendome and
Marathon, a small bouquet of wildflowers and one Mexican candle mark the
spot where Rangel.s brother Mario was gunned down 13 years earlier by
rival gang members and where Valentin himself was shot before stumbling
across the street to his apartment complex.
A deep fly ball from there, the type of urban hipsters who have
earned Silver Lake its bonhomie-boho image obliviously sip caf con
leches at the Tropical Caf and discuss Tsar.s latest show at Spaceland.
The two scenes illuminate the stubborn contrast between Silver Lake.s
chic main drag and the neighborhood south of Sunset Boulevard. In the
streets abutting Vendome and Marathon, a spate of gang violence that
started on Labor Day weekend has been responsible for several drive-bys,
a car bombing, two deaths, and the rattled nerves of longtime residents
and more recent arrivals who hoped the checkered neighborhood had made
the transition from barrio to bourgeois.
Though gang activity has long been a part of the landscape in
Silver Lake, particularly south of Sunset, residents say the recent
violence, which has sent at least 40 gunshots echoing through the
neighborhood, is unprecedented. On August 29, the first six shots took
the life of Rangel. Another gang-related shooting . possibly tied to
Rangel.s murder . only a week later and just blocks away on Bellevue
left an Angelino Heights gang member injured and his friend, 28-year-old
Juan Monsivais, dead. More recently, members of La Mirada gang unloaded
a hail of bullets across a busy park at an SUV they believed to be
carrying enemy gang members.
The level of gang violence occurring in this area, while far from
the city.s worst, is happening at the same time property values have
gone up 33 percent this year alone and .bargain. homes are selling for
more than a half-million dollars just north of Sunset. The unexpected
rash of violence here illustrates a gangs-versus-gentrification drama
that.s likely to play out in other neighborhoods across the city as the
overheated housing market pushes prospective new homeowners deeper into
the fringes of long-held gang turf.
"I think that people thought the property values would
automatically help with a problem like gangs, and I guess that.s not
necessarily the case. They can still come into the neighborhood and do
what they want," said Linda Froiland, who moved here three years
ago from Minnesota and who is co-president of the Silver Lake
Improvement Association.
Police are unsure how or even if the recent violence is connected.
Locals, though, point to a heated graffiti-tagging war between rival
gangs in the area, one headed by Rangel, as the spark.
By all accounts, and judging from the audacious way he.d sign his
name to his tags, Rangel was the main provocateur in the graffiti battle
that at first presented locals with more of a nuisance than a threat
when it flared up six months ago. His signature tag, .SL13Val,. sprayed
on the cars, homes and businesses in streets around Vendome and Marathon
became a common sight in the neighborhood. It was often scrawled over
18th Street gang graffiti. A former gang member familiar with the area
says Rangel was asserting control of the area for .recruiting, to sell
drugs and claim the street."
The gang member, who asked not to be identified, believes that
four gangs are currently vying for the drug trade that has been going on
in the area since the 1970s, when the 18th Street gang ruled the
streets. At one time, a dealer could make $800 a night selling dope on
the corner of Vendome and Marathon with little threat of being arrested.
Recently, the Aztlan member, who dealt out of his apartment on Vendome.
The back-and-forth tagging showed clearly, though, that the main
beef was between Rangel.s Silver Lake 13 and the 18th Street gangs.
Residents and observers speculate that police efforts to clear gangs
from MacArthur Park . where 18th Street had a stranglehold on the Bonnie
Brae drug traffic and was known to tax street vendors . as well as a
successful court injunction that made it illegal for 18th Street gang
members to congregate near their former stronghold in the Pico-Union
area, pushed them west in search of new turf.
"It is the supply-and-demand thing," said Froiland.
"There had been an illegal business operating here for 20 years.
When we got rid of the people, it became open territory for other gangs
to come in and sell drugs there."
Rangel, apparently, didn.t put out the welcome mat.
"They [18th Street] don't belong in this area," said a
longtime friend of Rangel.s who asked to remain anonymous. .Those guys
want to take over everywhere. Before, they stuck to MacArthur Park. They
have a shitty-ass town where they live. They get anyone in and they kill
their own people. They want to corrupt this side of town. Nobody wants
to see someone come to their house and start their own business
there."
.It is a matter of pride,. said Senior Lead Officer Al Polehonki
of the LAPD.s Northeast Division. .You aren.t going to let someone from
another gang spray in your area. If you are in a gang and another gang
comes by, it is like a challenge to you..
What started as a nuisance became more threatening when a Molotov
cocktail was thrown into a parked SUV just after midnight in July, weeks
before Rangel was gunned down. The firebomb smashed through the driver.s
window of the SUV, engulfing the vehicle in flames within seconds.
Residents, afraid the vehicle would explode, put out the fire long
before firemen arrived on the scene about a half-hour later.
Fears that animosities were heating up in the neighborhood were
confirmed on Friday, August 29, with the late-summer skies just faded to
black. The streets, where young children on scooters are a common sight,
were mostly bare at 8:55 p.m. except for Rangel, who was standing on the
northwest corner of Vendome and Marathon when a white Toyota minivan
pulled up alongside him. Two male Latinos jumped out of the car and
walked toward Rang | |